Spelling Rules

Writing Systems of the World

Course 1 · Chapter 9 · Spelling Rules

Chapters 2 to 8 were about the symbols. A script alone does not tell you how to write a language: you also need the conventions for which letters spell which sounds, which way the lines run, and what to do when a language has to be written in a script that is not its own. This chapter covers direction, orthography, English spelling and romanisation.

The idea in a box
Wikipedia's Orthography article describes an orthography as "a set of conventions for writing a language", covering spelling, punctuation, word boundaries, capitalisation, hyphenation and emphasis. The same script can carry very different orthographies.

Which Way Do the Lines Run?

From Wikipedia's Writing system article (first 100,000 of 154,316 characters read).

DirectionExamples (per the article)
Left to right, top to bottomThe Greek alphabet and its successors settled on this pattern
Right to leftArabic; Hebrew came to be written this way; the Phoenician direction "initially stabilized after c. 800 BC"
Vertical, top to bottom, columns left to rightMongolian script
Vertical, columns right to leftScripts using Chinese characters, traditionally
Bottom to topOgham (on the corner of a stone); Hanunoo lines move upward but are read left to right
Either way / alternatingEgyptian hieroglyphs (figures turned to face the start of the line); the early alphabet, most commonly written in alternating-direction (boustrophedon) lines
  • Why left to right? The article gives one reason for the Greek pattern: the hand does not interfere with what is being written, because most people are right-handed.
  • It can change. The article says horizontal left-to-right writing was widely adopted for Chinese-derived scripts only in the 20th century, due to Western influence.

Direction in Unicode

A computer storing mixed text keeps characters in reading order and gives each character a direction class. My own example, run and copied; the second part counts the ough-words in a sentence the English orthography article quotes.

import unicodedata for ch in ["a", "א", "ع", "語", "1", " "]: print(repr(ch), unicodedata.bidirectional(ch)) s = "Though the tough cough and hiccough plough him through" words = [w for w in s.lower().split() if "ough" in w] print(words) print(len(words))
'a' L 'א' R 'ع' AL '語' L '1' EN ' ' WS ['though', 'tough', 'cough', 'hiccough', 'plough', 'through'] 6

L is left-to-right, R right-to-left (Hebrew), AL is Arabic letter (also right to left), EN is a European number and WS is white space. The Chinese character is classed L, which matches the modern left-to-right practice in the article. Digits stay left-to-right inside right-to-left text; that is my observation from the class, not a claim from the article.

Orthography: Shallow and Deep

From Wikipedia's Orthography article (whole answer as returned).

  • Shallow. Spelling-to-sound correspondences are relatively simple and consistent. Spanish has a clear one-to-one correspondence between phonemes and graphemes, and Hawaiian uses only 13 letters.
  • Deep. Correspondences are highly complex or inconsistent; the article's example is Navajo.
  • Effect. Children learn to read faster in shallow orthographies like Spanish than in deep ones like English.
  • Regulators. Some nations use language academies, such as the Académie Française and the Royal Spanish Academy. English has none.
  • Reform. Noah Webster sought easily noticeable differences between American and British spelling (honor and honour). Modern Greek simplified its historical diacritics to a single accent.

Why English Spelling Is So Irregular

From Wikipedia's English orthography article (first 100,000 of 205,599 characters read).

CauseWhat the article says
Sound changeSpellings were largely derived from Middle English and generally do not reflect sound changes since the late 15th century, such as the Great Vowel Shift
PrintingEarly compositors, who were multilingual, sometimes used patterns from other languages; "ghost" was "gost" until a Flemish pattern was unintentionally substituted
LoanwordsForeign spellings are usually kept: Polish cz in Czech, Norwegian fj in fjord. Early Middle English respelled French imports, but this stopped after about 1400
Etymological respellingA "b" was added to debt and an "s" to island to suggest Latin or Greek origins
No regulator"English has never had any official regulating authority for spelling"
  • No one-to-one match. English has 24 to 27 consonant phonemes and 13 to 20 vowels but only 26 letters.
  • One sound, many spellings. The sound /uː/ can be spelled in up to 24 different ways, and /iː/ in at least 18 to 21. For /ʃ/ the article lists sh, ch (French loans), s (sugar), t (ration), c (ocean), ss (tissue), sch (schedule) and x (Chinese loans).
  • One spelling, many sounds. The letters ou can be pronounced in as many as nine different ways. The four-letter ough can be pronounced in at least ten different ways; the article cites Robert A. Heinlein's sentence "Though the tough cough and hiccough plough him through" to show it (the Python example above found six ough-words in it).
  • Silent letters. Examples listed: l in talk and half, w in two and sword, gh in night and brought, and the silent e.
  • Webster. He promoted more phonetic spellings in the United States, such as flavor, fiber, defense, analyze and catalog; the article says these forms already existed, but his dictionaries helped standardise them.
Watch out: irregular is not the same as random
Most oddities have a history, as the table shows, and the article says the spelling "generally do[es] not reflect" sound change, not that it ignores sound. Also, the article calls English spelling "considered irregular and complex compared to that of other languages", which is a comparison, not a claim that no pattern exists.

Romanisation

From Wikipedia's Romanization article (first 100,000 of 107,175 characters read). When a language needs writing in Latin letters for an outsider, the article distinguishes two aims:

AimPrincipleExamples (per the article)
TransliterationA one-to-one mapping of characters in the source into the target script; less weight on how the result soundsNihon-shiki for Japanese (1885); ISO 9 for Cyrillic (1995); BGN/PCGN (Russian version 1947)
TranscriptionRepresents speech; phonemic or phoneticHepburn for Japanese (1867), designed for English speakers; Hanyu Pinyin (1958); Revised Romanization of Korean (2000)
  • Pinyin has been used officially in China, adopted by much of the international community, and in Taiwan since 1 January 2009. The Revised Romanization of Korean replaced a modified McCune-Reischauer system used from 1984 to 2000.
  • For computers, ease of creation and storage matters: Harvard-Kyoto aims at 7-bit ASCII, ITRANS was once prevalent on Usenet, and wāpuro rōmaji is "not strictly a system, but a collection of common practices" for typing Japanese.
Note on sources
This chapter uses Wikipedia's Writing system (directionality section, first 100,000 characters), Orthography, English orthography (first 100,000 characters) and Romanization (first 100,000 characters) articles. The English orthography article did not mention color/colour, so I use honor and honour from the Orthography article instead; the Orthography article did not discuss the Great Vowel Shift, printing, Finnish or Italian, and the Romanization article did not mention the 1928 Turkish reform, so none appear. Counts and dates are the articles' and unchecked against primary scholarship. The table layouts, the Python example and the digit and Chinese-character observations are mine.

Try It Yourself

Exercise 1

Sort these into shallow or deep, using the Orthography article: Spanish, English, Hawaiian, Navajo. Then say what the article reports about learning to read in each kind.

📄 View solution
Exercise 2

Use the table of causes to explain why debt has a silent b and ghost has an h. Which cause covers each?

📄 View solution
Exercise 3

Run the Python direction check on three characters of your own (one each from different scripts). Which direction class does each report, and does it match the article's list of directions?

📄 View solution

Chapter 9 Quick Reference

  • Orthography: the conventions for writing a language (spelling, punctuation, word boundaries and more)
  • Shallow orthography (Spanish): simple sound-letter matches; deep (English, Navajo): complex or inconsistent
  • English irregularity: sound change, printing, loanwords, etymological respelling, no regulator
  • Romanisation: transliteration (character to character) versus transcription (sound to letters)
Coming next
Writing Systems of the World 10 is the last chapter: how lost scripts were deciphered, which scripts are in danger, and a recap of the whole course.