The Cultural Revolution: Mao's Real Power Struggle
Chinese Political History I: Empire's Fall, Revolution & Mao's China
Chapter 9 · The Cultural Revolution: Mao's Real Power Struggle
Chapter 8 closed with Mao ceding real, day-to-day economic leadership to Liu Shaoqi and Deng Xiaoping at the 1962 Seven Thousand Cadres Conference — a genuine retreat, but not a permanent one. This chapter traces what followed once Mao judged the moment right to reclaim the authority he had given up: a decade-long upheaval that consumed the party, the country, and very nearly the pragmatists who had stepped into the vacuum he had left.
Mao's Real Motivation
Mao launched the Cultural Revolution in May 1966, and its own real underlying purpose was less about the sweeping ideological language used to justify it than about reasserting Mao's personal political dominance. Having stepped back from front-line economic management after the Great Leap Forward's own catastrophic failure, Mao had watched Liu Shaoqi and Deng Xiaoping steadily accumulate real practical authority over the intervening years — and came to see the two pragmatists as a genuine threat to his own position. Framing the movement as a defense against "bourgeois elements" that had infiltrated government and society gave Mao a real ideological vehicle for eliminating his own rivals while consolidating personal power.
"Bombard the Headquarters" & Liu Shaoqi's Real Fall
Mao's own polemic "Bombard the Headquarters" directly targeted Liu Shaoqi, then serving as President, casting him as the personification of a "bourgeois headquarters" operating within the Party itself. The specific trigger was Liu's own disagreement with Mao's radical approach — particularly over Liu's use of work-teams to maintain order rather than allow the movement's own chaotic momentum to run unchecked. The consequences for Liu were swift and severe: his own rank within the party hierarchy collapsed from second to eighth, and he was removed from power entirely.
The Red Guards & the "Four Olds"
Mao's call to action mobilized a real, largely youthful movement — students and young activists organizing themselves into Red Guard units tasked with attacking the "Four Olds": old ideas, old customs, old culture, and old habits. The destruction this unleashed was genuinely severe and, in many cases, historically irreplaceable.
What was actually destroyed
Real, historically significant sites and artifacts — the Cemetery of Confucius, the Temple of Heaven, and the Ming tombs among them — were damaged or destroyed by Red Guard units acting in Mao's own name.
What the destruction was meant to achieve
The campaign's own stated purpose was purging capitalist and traditional elements from Chinese society — a goal that, in real practice, extended to erasing physical monuments of China's own pre-revolutionary past.
Deng Xiaoping's Real Purge
Deng Xiaoping, closely associated with Liu Shaoqi's own pragmatic economic policies, was similarly sidelined during the movement's early purges. He initially retained his own seat on the Politburo, a real, if temporary, distinction from Liu's own complete removal — but Deng would face further, more severe persecution as the Cultural Revolution's own political tides continued to shift over the following years.
The Lin Biao Affair (1971)
Lin Biao, elevated to vice-chairman following Liu Shaoqi's own fall, emerged as Mao's presumed successor in the movement's early years. That relationship deteriorated over time, culminating in a genuinely mysterious 1971 plane crash that killed Lin — officially attributed to a failed coup attempt against Mao, code-named Project 571. The affair remains, in real terms, one of the more genuinely opaque episodes of the entire period, with several specific details of what actually happened never fully and independently verified.
The Gang of Four's Real Rise
In the wake of Lin Biao's own death, a new radical faction moved to consolidate influence around Mao — Jiang Qing, Mao's own wife, alongside three close allies: Zhang Chunqiao, Yao Wenyuan, and Wang Hongwen. This group, later known as the Gang of Four, had achieved real, substantial political influence by 1972, and continued championing the movement's own most radical policies for the remainder of Mao's life.
The Real, Disputed Death Toll
The Cultural Revolution's own human cost, like the Great Leap Forward's famine traced in Chapter 8, is genuinely disputed among historians — estimates commonly range from 1 million to 2 million deaths. Documented regional violence included real, severe massacres in Guangxi, Beijing, Inner Mongolia, Guangdong, Yunnan, and Hunan, with the Guangxi violence in particular including well-documented instances of cannibalism carried out in an atmosphere of extreme political frenzy and impunity.
Mao's Death & the Gang of Four's Arrest
Mao Zedong died in September 1976, and within weeks, the Gang of Four were arrested in October 1976 — a real, decisive act that formally brought the Cultural Revolution to its own close after roughly a decade of upheaval.
Mao's own death did not, by itself, settle who would actually lead China next. Chapter 10 closes this course with the real power struggle that followed immediately afterward — the Gang of Four's own arrest as only the opening move, and Deng Xiaoping's genuine, second return from political exile to reshape China's own direction for decades to come.
Hands-On Exercises
Explain why Mao's own real motivation for launching the Cultural Revolution is better understood as reclaiming personal authority than as the ideological anti-bourgeois campaign it was officially presented as.
Explain why Deng Xiaoping initially retaining his Politburo seat, while Liu Shaoqi was removed from power entirely, is meaningful evidence about how the purges actually unfolded, rather than simply a minor procedural detail.
Explain why the Chinese Communist Party's own official 1981 verdict on the Cultural Revolution carries a different, real significance than an equivalent judgment reached only by outside historians.
Quick Reference
- May 1966: Mao launches the Cultural Revolution, primarily to reclaim authority from Liu Shaoqi and Deng Xiaoping
- "Bombard the Headquarters": Mao's polemic targets Liu Shaoqi, whose rank collapses from second to eighth before his removal from power
- Red Guards: youth-led units attack the "Four Olds," destroying sites including the Cemetery of Confucius and the Ming tombs
- 1971 Lin Biao affair: Mao's presumed successor dies in a genuinely mysterious plane crash, officially tied to a failed coup (Project 571)
- Gang of Four: Jiang Qing, Zhang Chunqiao, Yao Wenyuan, and Wang Hongwen achieve real influence by 1972
- Real, disputed death toll: commonly estimated at 1–2 million, including documented regional massacres
- September–October 1976: Mao dies; the Gang of Four are arrested weeks later, formally ending the movement
- 1981: the CCP's own official verdict calls the period "the most severe setback and heaviest losses" since 1949