sindarin_grammar1-4 Exercise 3: The Puzzle of i-Pheriannath ============================================================ The soft table says p -> b after the article i. But the attested form i-Pheriannath has ph. So the text does not follow the neat table, and a learner cannot assume the table predicts every attested form. Why be cautious about any single chart: charts from different sources give different outputs for the same letter, disagree on the number of mutations, and name them differently. Tolkien's texts are the anchor; the charts are scholars' proposals.