Cases 2

Quenya Grammar 1

Course 1 · Chapter 5 · Cases 2

Quenya Grammar 1, Chapter 4 covered the cases that show who does what: subject, object, owner, receiver. This chapter covers the cases that answer "where?" and "with what?". English uses small words such as to, in, from and with; Quenya adds an ending to the noun instead. As before, the forms come from the "Plotz declension" (a 1967 letter of Tolkien), which gives full paradigms for cirya "ship" and lassë "leaf".

The idea in a box
Four endings do the work of English "to", "in", "from" and "with": allative (towards), locative (at, in), ablative (away from) and instrumental (by means of). Each has a singular, plural and dual form.

The Singular Endings

CaseMeaningcirya "ship"lassë "leaf"
Allativemotion towardsciryannalassenna
Locativelocation, positionciryassëlassessë
Short locativeshortened locativeciryaslasses
Ablativemotion away fromciryallolassello
Instrumentalmeans or instrumentciryanenlassenen

Look at the patterns: allative -nna, locative -ssë, ablative -llo, instrumental -nen. Wikipedia notes that the dative from Chapter 4 (ciryan) is a shortened form of the allative (ciryanna). For lassë the final -ë becomes -e- before the ending (lassenna), which the table shows.

Examples in Use

# Examples given on the Wikipedia page, with its glosses elenna toward a star, starward(s) allative of elen "star" Lóriendesse in Lórien locative earello from the sea ablative an i falmali = i falmalinna(r) upon the many waves the ending -nna corresponds to an

The last line shows two ways to say the same thing: a small word (an) with the plural partitive noun falmali, or the same noun with the allative ending (falmalinna(r)). The page gives no example of the instrumental, so this chapter does not invent one.

With Number

Each case has its own endings in the plural and dual. In the table, "Pl. 1" is the general plural (-r or -i) and "Pl. 2" is the partitive plural (-li) from Chapter 3. Forms are those the page prints for the formal register.

Casecirya Pl. 1lassë Pl. 1cirya Pl. 2cirya Duallassë Dual
Allativeciryannarlassennarciryalinna(r)ciryantalassenta
Locativeciryassenlassessenciryalisse(n)ciryatsëlassetsë
Short locativeciryaislassisciryalis(not given)(not given)
Ablativeciryallonlassellonciryalillo(n)ciryaltolasselto
Instrumentalciryainenlassínenciryalínenciryantenlassenten

The pattern to learn: the plural ending is the singular one with a final -n or -r added (-llo to -llon; -ssë to -ssen; -nna to -nnar), and the partitive plural puts -li- before the case ending (ciryalinna(r)). The brackets show that the page gives the final consonant as optional.

Choosing the Right Case

  1. Is something moving? Towards it: allative. Away from it: ablative.
  2. Is it staying in a place? Locative (or the short locative).
  3. Is the noun a tool or means? Instrumental.
  4. Does the noun belong to origin or ownership? Back to the genitive of Chapter 4.
Watch out: formal forms, not everyday
The tables are the formal register (Parmaquesta). Wikipedia gives no full everyday (Tarquesta) paradigm, and says only that the formal long -í plural has unpublished rules. A form such as lassínen is therefore a formal form and may not match what everyday Quenya would use.
Watch out: gaps
The page gives no example of the instrumental, no dual form of the short locative, and no explanation of how the cases are used with the dual. Nouns other than cirya and lassë are not covered here because their forms come from an earlier period (about 1935) and have blanks.
Not yet verified
The forms and glosses come from a summary of Wikipedia's "Grammar of late Quenya"; I did not read the page itself or Tolkien's letter. The patterns "plural = singular + -n or -r" and "-li- before the case ending" are my reading of the table cells, not stated rules. The advice for "choosing the right case" is my own teaching summary. I could not find in the page the Namárië place-names or phrases I had hoped to use (such as Valimar and Mar-nu-Falmar), so this chapter does not claim anything about them.
Sources for this chapter
Wikipedia, "Grammar of late Quenya" (cases section, two readings through summaries).

Hands-On Exercises

Exercise 1

Give the allative, locative, ablative and instrumental singular of cirya and lassë from the table, then translate "from the ship", "to the leaf", "in the ship" and "with the leaf" (leave out the article for now).

📄 View solution
Exercise 2

Explain the two ways of saying "upon the many waves", name the case ending involved, and say which of the two is the short, noun-only form.

📄 View solution
Exercise 3

Take ciryallon and ciryalillo(n). Break each into noun, number ending and case ending, say how they differ in meaning, and label them attested or built by rule.

📄 View solution

Chapter 5 Quick Reference

  • Allative -nna (towards), locative -ssë (in, at; short -s), ablative -llo (from), instrumental -nen (by means of)
  • Plural: add -n or -r (-llon, -ssen, -nnar); partitive adds -li- first (ciryalinna(r))
  • Dual: -nta, -tsë, -lto, -nten (ciryanta, ciryatsë, ciryalto, ciryanten)
  • Attested glosses: elenna "toward a star"; Lóriendesse "in Lórien"; earello "from the sea"; an i falmali = i falmalinna(r) "upon the many waves"
Coming next
Quenya Grammar 1, Chapter 6 turns to adjectives: how they agree with the noun, where they stand, and how they are compared.