debundesliga1-9, Exercise 2: RB Leipzig and the German model

Model answer:

For (a fit): the club follows the rules as written, brought top-flight football to the East, has a successful youth system and fills its stadium.

Against: it was created by a company and controlled by a few members, so critics say it follows the letter but not the spirit of 50+1; the name and branding raise questions; and some supporters' groups reject the club.

A balanced answer states both views and notes that the answer depends on whether one judges by the rule's wording or its purpose. The course takes no side; details should be checked.